Appearance
question:How does Hornby's writing style in "Songbook" compare to his previous work, particularly his novel "High Fidelity," and what makes it effective at conveying his personal connection to the songs he discusses?: HORNBY1/C/10SEPT96/DD/TKAO= was at Kepler's book store in Menlo Park yesterday afternoon autographying his "High Fidelity". Photo by Tim Kao, the Chronicle. On page 118 of his delightful, let's hope influential new book, Nick Hornby makes a startling admission. It comes as he's writing, a little defensively, about his late-onset love for Jackson Browne's 1974 song "Late for the Sky." "This may simply mean," he says of his newfound tolerance for Browne's mellow, heartfelt songcraft, "that I have become old, and so Jackson Browne's sedate music holds more appeal than punk -- that all this is a long- winded way of saying that I'm forty-five (today, as I write!), and so I listen to folky singer-songwriters, not bratty and loud guitar bands." It's the start of an amiably longish sentence, like many of Hornby's, with perhaps more "thats" in it than generally advisable, so there would be no shame in missing the implications of that parenthetical exclamation. But think about it: Hornby wrote this essay on his birthday. Maybe things are different over in England, where Hornby lives, but here, birthdays are not for working. Birthdays are for having fun, for making the most of; in other words, for making oneself miserable trying to come up with something that'll still be memorable a week later, when someone innocently asks what you did for your birthday. That Hornby spent his birthday writing a rueful, sneaky-profound essay about growing older suggests that he may actually enjoy his work. Maybe that helps explain why his readers enjoy it, too -- so much, in fact, that many of us would happily spend even precious birthday hours reading him. collection of 26 exemplary essays about songs Hornby loves, accompanied by a CD containing 11 of them that his publisher could actually secure the rights to. The book's a joint benefit for the TreeHouse Trust, which helps autistic kids like Hornby's son, and 826 Valencia, the San Francisco learning center co- founded by McSweeney's publisher Dave Eggers in his continuing effort to use his fame -- as Maxwell Smart used to say -- for niceness, instead of evil. But it would be a mistake to dismiss "Songbook," or even to cherish it, as just a good-hearted lark, a toss-off aimed at the obsessed vinyl-heads Hornby diagnosed so knowingly in his novel "High Fidelity." That whole subculture, all those mournful guys to whom the sound of record-store bin dividers clicking by is almost music enough, should love "Songbook," yet so should anyone interested in great essays, or in the delicate art of being funny, or in how to write about one's feelings in such a way that other people will actually care. "The dance floor is still, to me, the social equivalent of the North Sea during English seaside holidays -- something to be treated with the utmost fear and caution, something you walk towards and away from over a period of several hours while battling with your own courage, something you plunge into briefly and uncomfortably while every corpuscle in your blood screams at you to get out before it's too late, something that leaves lots of important parts of you feeling shrivelled." Maybe Hornby can't dance, but he's got rhythm to burn. Like Hornby's essays, the best writing about music shouldn't just make a reader want to play a song immediately, which can be tricky with "Songbook" as the CD's only track list appears on the surface of the disc itself. The best music writing should linger like an unshakable tune, haunting readers even years later, after too many hours between headphones have long since deafened us to the actual notes. When "Songbook" doesn't win all the literary prizes it should -- too unpretentious, too funny, not rigorous enough -- somebody should think seriously about entering it in the running for next year's album notes Grammy. So what if the ratio of text to music is a tad top-heavy? So what if Hornby's informal, self-interrupting, almost dictated-sounding prose has to backtrack out of the occasional parenthetical cul de sac? Like his admitted literary heroine, Anne Tyler, Hornby expresses the embarrassing particularity of human behavior down to the semiquaver. Why doesn't anybody write about books with the same personal, visceral immediacy that Hornby brings to writing about songs?
answer:Hornby's writing style in "Songbook" differs from his previous work, particularly his novel "High Fidelity," in that it is more personal and focused on his connection to specific songs. In "High Fidelity," Hornby uses music as a theme to explore broader themes of relationships and identity, while in "Songbook," the music is the central focus. Hornby's writing in "Songbook" is also more intimate, as he shares personal anecdotes and memories tied to each song he discusses. Hornby's writing style in "Songbook" is effective at conveying his personal connection to the songs he discusses because he approaches each essay as a fan, rather than as a critic or expert. His love for each song shines through in his writing, making the reader feel a similar emotional connection. Hornby's writing is also accessible and relatable, as he writes in a conversational style that makes the reader feel like they are having a conversation with him. Overall, Hornby's writing style in "Songbook" is a departure from his previous work, but it is effective at conveying his personal connection to music and making the reader feel the same emotional connection.
question:Can you provide examples of specific songs that Hornby discusses in "Songbook"?
answer:Yes, here are some examples of specific songs that Hornby discusses in "Songbook": - "Thunder Road" by Bruce Springsteen - "Heartbreaker" by Led Zeppelin - "Your Song" by Elton John - "Think" by Aretha Franklin - "I'm Like a Bird" by Nelly Furtado - "Born to Run" by Bruce Springsteen - "Set the Fire to the Third Bar" by Snow Patrol - "Raindrops Keep Fallin' on My Head" by B.J. Thomas - "Hallelujah" by Leonard Cohen - "Lose Yourself" by Eminem
question:Can you provide a brief summary of the overall theme of "Songbook" and why it is significant?
answer:The overall theme of "Songbook" is the significance of music in our lives and the emotional connections we form with certain songs. Hornby uses his own personal experiences and memories tied to specific songs to explore this theme. Through his essays, Hornby emphasizes the power of music to evoke emotions, capture moments in time, and provide comfort and understanding. The significance of "Songbook" lies in its exploration of the intimate relationship between music and our personal lives. It reminds readers of the important role that music plays in shaping our memories and emotions, and how it can bring people together in shared experiences. Additionally, the book serves as a celebration of the beauty and power of music, and its ability to impact us in profound ways.
question:Can you provide some examples of how Hornby's personal anecdotes and memories enhance his discussions of the songs in "Songbook"?
answer:Certainly! Here are a few examples of how Hornby's personal anecdotes and memories enhance his discussions of the songs in "Songbook": - In his essay on Bruce Springsteen's "Thunder Road," Hornby shares a story about a failed attempt to get a girl to go out with him by playing her the song. He frames the song as a powerful expression of longing and the desire for connection, and his personal anecdote reinforces this idea. - In his essay on Led Zeppelin's "Heartbreaker," Hornby talks about how the song was a favorite of his during his teenage years. He connects this to the time in his life when he was discovering his own taste in music and shaping his identity. - In his essay on Nelly Furtado's "I'm Like a Bird," Hornby discusses how the song was popular during a difficult time in his life when he was going through a divorce. He talks about how the song provided comfort and a sense of hope during this time. - In his essay on Leonard Cohen's "Hallelujah," Hornby shares a personal anecdote about how the song played at a friend's funeral. He talks about how the song's themes of love, loss, and redemption resonated with him and others in attendance during this difficult time. Overall, Hornby's personal anecdotes and memories provide context and emotional weight to his discussions of the songs. They help to emphasize the ways in which music plays a crucial role in shaping our experiences and memories.